About Expert


Key Topics
The Task: You will write a thesis-driven paper that responds directly to one or more arguments you have encountered through class readings. To do this, you should choose one or more class reading(s) that present(s) a position, summarize and analyze that position, and then respond to it with your own thesis. How you respond to the chosen text is completely up to you: you can agree with the author; you can disagree with the author; or you can combine agreement and disagreement. In any case, you must explain your position thoroughly. Note: You should not find outside sources for this paper; only use class readings.
The author has discussed the history, literature, and regional identity and states that the American Midwest has some differences from the other western countries. Moreover, the author also asserts that the generally in the Midwest, there are associations with the past individuals along with the trails of stories that are followed after the same. These stories consequently build identities of these areas. The regions other than the Midwest have limited historical images and most of the local identity can be found to be prevalent which is later generalized to whole populace. On the other hand, the Midwest can be observed heaving more locale meaning.
The author has tried to link the history, literature and the regional identity and states that the Midwest differ significantly from the other areas however certainly this is not the condition always. There are times when one can find the combination of one form getting combined with the other and showing the blend of elements coming forward. Moreover, it has been also identified that the author has statements showing the development of local meanings that are dense in Midwest which is observed by the external individuals as empty. It can be stated that the Midwest is no different than the other areas if some of the central idea of literature development is taken into consideration.
There are arguments from the author that the identity of the Midwest is not concentrated to any single entity and is mixed with multiple small and big stories, thus leaving the outsiders confused of the actual identity. The argument goes ahead with the statement that there are no specific historical roots that can build the individual identity of the Midwest. However, this argument cannot be accepted on the ground that the existence of specific historical background is evident in the region as the lack of the same could not have given rise to the interesting pieces of literatures that have been weaved around these lives.
There are some instances when the author asserts that the region lacks certain identity. Moreover, it has been stated that these uncertain identity mostly leads to the formation of regional pride that creeps in the individuals residing in these areas. However, here it can be stated that regional pride generally comes when the individuals residing in the area can associate themselves with the regional identity. The presence of insignificant identity and having regional pride do not collate together properly. On the other hand, one can amply find instances when the significant identity generally results in the pride.
On one aspect it can be agreed with the author that the representation of Midwest as a whole through a single literary piece is challenging. There exist multifaceted identities that challenge the writers who are trying to articulate what they try to see as a whole. There is multiple cultures and the same can be reflected in the literature pieces that have come from time to time. Stating or defining the Midwest under single culture can be challenging yet interesting.
The presence of Midwestern history or football need not be confusing to the people of Midwest and the simple argument that can be put forth for the same is that history is not always what happened ten decades ago. The present is bound to convert into history and formation of activities and elements that have the ability to sow seed to unison or single identity should be appreciated. Moreover, regional identity connects things together with the fine thread that can be found to be present in the Midwest.